Archive for the ‘Steve Palm Monthly Reports’ Category

February Market Update

Tuesday, March 20th, 2007

There were 4,924 closings for all single family in February. This is a decline of 9.5% over February 2006 and the 6th consecutive period decline.

Single family detached closed 4,181 units in February, or a decline of 9.9% from the same year ago period. This is the 7th consecutive monthly decline, but none of the percentage decreases have been double digit. We have slowed, but not drastically.Condos and townhomes had 743 closings in February, or a decline of 7.1%. After reporting a double-digit percentage increase in January, the trend has reversed again in February. This is also the 4

th decline for condos and townhomes over the past six periods.

The average sale price for condos and townhomes was unchanged in February from the same year ago period. The average was $192,811 versus $192, 763 for February 2006.

The average sale price for single family detached was $254,659 or an increase of 2.6% over February 2006. With continued demand and increasing inventories, I do not expect any significant appreciation of home prices this spring. Price increases for single family detached of 5.2% in January and 2.6% in February will be on the “high” side for the first half of 2007.

Inventories of homes for sale is at all-time highs for Atlanta. When inventories are at records high and demand is “flat” or down, then many indicators and other factors are at all-time highs too.

The months supply for single family detached was at 8.4 at the end of February. This is a record and all indications are that this will continue to rise over the next few months.

The single family detached 12 month moving average for months-supply was at an all-time high at the end of February. The 12-month average was 7.6 and the previous high was in August 2003.

There were 6,161 expired single family detached listings for the first two periods in 2007. This is an increase of almost 1,900 expired listings over the same two periods for 2006 and almost 50% of the entire total of expired listings for 2000.

The number of withdrawn listings keeps surging too, as there were 4,315 withdrawn listing for all single family for the first periods in 2007. This is a large increase over the 2,736 withdrawn listings for the same two periods in 2006.

Days on market was at 90.5 for single family detached in February. This is the first time DOM has been above 90 for single family detached since February 1998.

I have gone over a lot of negative trends in this recap, but there are some positives too. Atlanta’s housing market has slowed, but not dropped significantly like some other metro housing markets. Right now is one of the best times to buy a home, as we have interest rates on the decline again, low unemployment, and affordable homes.

Thank you,

Steve Palm
Smart Numbers
© 2007 Smart Numbers

Popularity: 9% [?]

January Market Update

Tuesday, February 20th, 2007

There were 4,454 closings for all single family detached to start out the first period of 2007. This was down 8.1% from January 2006, but after lags are reported the decline will be much less.

This is a good sign. The decline of 8.1% is less than December’s 10.4% decline with no lags. This will probably be the best year-to-year change-reporting period for closings since August 2006 when we had a modest 1.3% increase.

Single family detached had 3,434 closings for January or a year-to-year decline of 9.8%. This will be the 6th consecutive decline after 40 consecutive increases.

Condos and townhomes had 658 closings or an increase of 1.9% from January 2006. This is a good improvement from December’s 9.0% decline with lags reported.

The average sale price in January for single family detached was $254,388. This was increase of 5.6% from January 2006 and the largest year-to-year period increase since December 2005. This may be another sign that the housing market may be starting to “turn the corner.”

The average sale price for condos and townhomes was $190,450 or a decline of 0.6% from January 2006. This is the main reason why condos and townhomes had an increase, while single family detached had a decline in closings.

The overall inventory of homes for sale is going through some extreme status changes. This can be expected in a slow housing market with high inventories.

The number of expired listings in January for all single family detached was 5,505. This is up almost 30% from January 2006. However, that increase is small compared to withdrawn listings reported in January. There were 2,246 withdrawn listings or an increase of 65% over January 2006.

There were a combined 16,000 expired and withdrawn listings for both December 2006 and January 2007. That is 60% more than what closed for all single family.

I am including the year-to year inventory trending grid. At the end of December a lot of consumers have taken their properties off the market for the holidays, so it very common to see upward shifts in months supply in January and 2007 was very indicative of this trend.

MonthsSupply

01/31/2006

MonthsSupply

01/31/2007 % Change

New - Single Family Detached 7.6 12.0 57.9%

New - Condos & Townhomes 7.1 10.5 47.9%

Resale - Single Family Detached 5.7 7.0 22.8%

Resale - Condos & Townhomes 8.8 8.5 -3.4%

The day-on-market for January was 90.6 for all single family. This is the second consecutive period above 90 days and the first time this has happened since 1998.

I believe the slowdown in housing has damaged our economy enough that an interest rate cut, not a hike is needed. This could take place, hopefully, before our summer season.

Thank you,

Steve Palm
Smart Numbers
© 2007 Smart Numbers

Popularity: 9% [?]

December Market Update

Sunday, January 21st, 2007

We are reporting on very different year-end statistics than we did a year ago. At the end of 2006 we had a down housing market compared to the end of 2005 when housing was really exploding up.

There were 80,308 closings for all single family in 2006. This was still an increase over 2005 by 2.5% or 2,000 closings. Detached single family was up 1.2%, while condos and townhomes were up a very respectable 10.5% in 2006.

In December there were 5,549 closings for all single family. This is a decrease of 14.2% from December 2005 and the 4th consecutive monthly decline. Detached single family was down 14.3% or the 5th consecutive decline, while condos and townhomes were down 13.8% or the 3rddecline over the past 4 periods.

The average sale price for all single family for 2006 was $250,483 or only a 2.1% increase over 2005. This is the smallest percentage increase since records have been kept. The average sale price for the past 5 periods (August-December) was only up 1% from the same year ago time frame.

The average sale price for single family detached was $260,723 for 2006, while condos and townhomes had an average price of $192,495.

The average price for condos and townhomes for December was $200,158 and the first time that the average was above $200M.

Many records were broken for expired and withdrawn listings for both the month and the year for December and 2006. There were 21,942 withdrawn listings for all single family or 4,200 more than 2005’s record high. There were also 56,094 expired listings for all single family or almost 5,000 more than 2004’s record high.

In December there were 1,301 expired listings for condos and townhomes and 5,804 expired listings for detached single family. Both of these set record highs easily surpassing 1,091 in December 05 and 5,611 in September 06.

Days on market ended the year at 79.3 for all single family. This was unchanged from 2005, while single family detached was down .04 days at 77.2 and condos and townhomes were up 1.1 days at 91.0.

Below is a chart that really sums up our year-to-year housing market from 2005 to 2006. I have always stated that months supply is the best gauge for the “health” of a housing market. The higher the months supply the weaker the market and visa versa.

12/31/2005 12/31/2006 % Change

New - Single Family Detached 7.4 11.2 51.4%

New - Condos & Townhomes 6.9 9.6 39.1%

Resale - Single Family Detached 5.4 6.5 20.4%

Resale - Condos & Townhomes 8.5 8 -5.9%

As you can see, months supply is much greater for the “high priced” new construction and has increased dramatically over the past year. In 2007, demand for the lower priced resales and discounting on high priced lots for new construction should reverse this trend.

Interest rates need to remain low and employment levels remain high, so that housing can rebound in 2007. This should be by the end of the second quarter or in the third quarter 2007.

Thank you,

Steve Palm
Smart Numbers
© 2007 Smart Numbers

Popularity: 8% [?]

November Market Update

Thursday, December 21st, 2006

A lot of negative news will be reported this period. However, after I report on the downers, I will share some encouraging numbers.

All single family housing closed 5,182 units in November. This is down 15% from November 2005 and will be the first three consecutive year-to-year declines since the 4th quarter 1999. Those three periods in 1999 had declines averaging less than 3%, while our last three periods will have an average percentage decline of over 6%.Single family attached was down 15% and condos and townhomes were down 15.4%. This was the second decline in the last three-quarters for condos and townhomes, while it was the 4th consecutive monthly decline for detached.

Our housing market was very strong from 12/2005 to 6/2006, so in order to see positive year-to-year changes, there definitely needs to be much more demand than we have experienced the past few periods.

The average sale price for single family detached was $257,676 in November. This was an increase of only 1.7% from the same year ago period and for the year the detached market is only up 2.4% from 2005’s average price. If the year-to-year percentage change is 2.6% or less, it will be the lowest year-to-year percentage change since data has been reported, 1994-1995.

Condos and townhomes had an average sale price of $192,901 for November or a 4.2% increase over November 2005. For the year, the average price for condos and townhomes are up 2.9% over 2005.

The two sectors that have slowed the most are new homes and the high-end home market. The months supply for single family detached new construction increased from 11.2 at the end of October to 11.5 at the end of November.

The months supply for condo and townhome new construction increased from 9.7 at the end of October to 10.0 at the end of November.

The months supply for single family detached resales decreased from 7.3 at the end of October to 7.1 at the end of November. The months supply for condo and townhome resales decreased from 9.2 at the end of October to 8.8 at the end of November.

Why the difference from new homes? Lot prices have appreciated 45% from 2003-2006 in Metro Atlanta. This is much greater than the appreciation rate for the resale market and currently resales provide a greater overall value for the consumer than new construction. However, after increased demand for resales and some discounting for new construction we should see demand again increase for new construction.

There is a bright spot at the end of November. Pending sales declined 7.3% in 2005 from the end of October to the end of November. However, they have declined only 2% for the same period in 2006. Those low home prices may be starting to be too attractive?

Interest rates have declined since their high on 6/29/06. If rates can remain low, home prices continue to moderate and employment remains high then we can reverse our recent downturns into positive gains in 2007. I believe rates will remain low, and with low demand home prices will remain flat, so the key will be employment. Housing “bailed” out our dot-com crash and economy after 4/2000. Now we need to have our economy remain strong for a 2007 housing recovery.

Thank you,

Steve Palm
Smart Numbers
© 2006 Smart Numbers

Popularity: 8% [?]

October Market Update

Tuesday, November 21st, 2006

Single family detached had another down period in October. There were 4,686 closings compared to 5,484 for October 05’ or a decrease of 14.6%. This is the fourth consecutive decline for single family detached housing. The last time this occurred was 10/99-01/00.

Condos and townhomes reversed their year-to-year decrease in September, as 871 condos and townhomes were closed in October or an increase of 2.0% from the same year ago period. Even with our slow down in real estate, condos and townhomes will have more closings after November than were reported for all of 2005.

For the year, there have been almost 3,000 more single-family closings than through October 2005. Compared to other markets that Smartnumbers follows, Atlanta has experienced a much milder housing slowdown. Some of the Florida markets are down over 30% year to year.

For the first time in almost five years, we are reporting a drop for a monthly year-to-year average sale price for single family detached. The average sale price in October for single family detached was $248,989 or a decline of 1.5% from October 2005’s average price of $252,730.

It was anticipated that when we slowed and inventories would rise that there would be pressure on prices to decline.

For the year, single family detached is 2.5% higher than 2005 and just another indication that the Atlanta housing slowdown will be a soft one.

The average price for condos and townhomes was $190,472. This is 3.8% higher than October 2005 and the largest increase since May. For the year, the average sale price for condos and townhomes is 2.8% higher than 2005.

The inventory level for single family has increased significantly since the end of February. There were 44,000 homes for sale for all single family at the beginning of March compared to almost 55,000 units at the end of October. There will be continued pressure on prices to come down with the large in inventory.

At the end of October, the months-supply for detached single family was at 8 months. This is just below the highest point recorded over the past 10 years of 8.1 at the end of May 2003. By the end of November, this mark will most likely be exceeded.

The months-supply for condos and townhomes at the end of October was 8.6. This is still far below the ten year high of almost 12 that was recorded three years ago.

There were almost as many expired listings as there were closings for all single family in October. There were 5,354 expired listings versus 5,557 units closed. However, if you added the 2,139 withdrawn listings, there were more listings expiring and being withdrawn than units closing.

We are in a slow down and I believe we are at or near the bottom. If interest rates and unemployment remain low combined with pent-up demand and moderating prices, we could have a rebound in the spring.

Thank you,

Steve Palm
Smart Numbers
© 2006 Smart Numbers

Popularity: 8% [?]

September Market Update

Friday, October 20th, 2006

There is a lot of negative news to report this period. However, we all knew this was going to happen, Smartnumbers predicted it would happen back in 2005, and we also know that we should have a fairly quick turnaround.

For the second consecutive period the year-to-year change for single family closings will be negative. There were 5,180 single family detached closings in September. This was down 14.5% from September 2005 and is our largest negative percentage change since March 2003.

There were 899 closings for townhomes and condominiums in September. This is down 15% from the same year ago period and will be the first period year-to-year negative change since March 2003.

There were 6,079 closings for all single family in September or a year-to-year decline of 14.5%. This is also the largest decline since March 2003 and also the second consecutive year-to-year negative period change.

The average sale price for single family detached closings in September was $258,278. This was only 1% higher than September 2005 and way below 2005’s 6.3% increase over 2004. This was also $18,000 less than our all-time high that was established in July.

The average sale price for condos and townhomes was $193,338 for September. This was an increase of 1.2% from the same year ago period and still a larger percentage increase than the 2004-2005 and 2003-2004 annual reporting periods. Reviewing the average sale price charts, please note how the average sale price for condos and townhomes has not changed much over the past few years.

When there is high inventory and slowing demand you can expect a lot of expired listings. September broke the record for the most expired single-family listings for a given period. There were 5,605 expired listings for all single family, which exceeded the previous high of 5,551 in December 2005. Before the year is out you can expect this record to be broken again.

There were 2,082 withdrawn listings and the average days-on-market was 77.7 for all single family in September.

The months supply of inventory increased again in September, but was concentrated more towards new homes rather than resales. The months supply for single family detached – new construction went from 10.0 in August to 10.5 in September. The months supply for condos and townhomes – new construction went from 8.4 in August to 8.8 in September. However, the months supply for single family detached – resales went from 7.4 in August to 7.3
in September and the months supply for condos and townhomes - resales went from 9.5 in August to 9.1 in September.

If you’re an agent in the high end housing market you need to concentrate your efforts within and around the Perimeter, as in any housing downturn the high-end “rural” markets are affected the most and are the last segment to turn the corner.

Thank you,
Steve Palm
Smart Numbers
© 2006 Smart Numbers

Popularity: 8% [?]

August Market Update

Thursday, September 21st, 2006

The Atlanta housing market is showing more signs of a slowdown. Single family detached housing closed 6,184 units in August. This is down 7.2% from August 05’and after lagged closings are reported, will probably still be down.

Single family detached closings are still negative for July year-to-year. Even after lags have been reported, single family detached is down 1.4%. Taking into account the results for July and August there is a very good chance that after September is reported we may have our first detached year-to-year down quarter since 1st quarter 2003.

Our streak for consecutive double-digit year-to-year increases for condos and townhomes looks to be in jeopardy. There were 1,046 condo and townhome closings in August. This is a decrease of 2% from August 2005 and after lags are reported we should have an increase, but not a double digit one.

The average sale price for single family detached in August was $267,174. This is an increase of 2.5% from the same year ago period. This was also the sixth out of eight 2006 reporting periods that have had a year to year change for single family detached that is below the lowest change for all of 2005.

Through eight periods of 2006 we have an average sale price for single family detached of $263,287. This is an increase of 3.3% over 2005, but 2005 had an increase of 6.3% over 2004.
Condos and townhomes had an average price of $186,669, which is unchanged from July 2005 and all of 2005.

Our inventory keeps increasing. Single family detached - new went from 9.4 to 10.0 (months-supply), condos and townhomes – new went from 7.6 to 8.4, single family detached – resale went from 7.2 to 7.4, and condos and townhomes – resale went from 9.4 to 9.5. As you can see, all categories for months supply went up from July 2005, but the “higher” priced new homes increased much more than resales.

Expired listings had a large year-to-year increase in August. The number of expired listings for all single family was 5,031 compared to 4,193 a year ago. This was the 9th consecutive increase and the largest unit increase since May 2003. With our increasing inventory and slowing of demand, the number expired listings will very likely break all-time records by the end of 2006.

The number of withdrawn listings for all single family was 2,304 in August. This was an all-time high and our third straight month we have had over 2,000 withdrawn single family listings.
I have mentioned a number of negative trends, but now for the good. Atlanta is slowing, but not nearly as bad as in other markets, i.e. Florida, West Coast, and Northeast, etc. I believe that Atlanta will have a “soft” landing or minimal slowing that should not last more than a few quarters. Interest rates have declined since 6/29 and gasoline prices have tumbled back down over a $1 off their highs of a month ago.

If we can maintain these recent positive economic trends, plus have unemployment remain low and interest rates not increase, housing will improve.

Thank you,
Steve Palm
Smart Numbers
© 2006 Smart Numbers

Popularity: 8% [?]

July Market Update

Monday, August 21st, 2006

July produced positive increases in units-closed and average prices, but there were also a couple of negative trends that very likely could continue through for the rest of the year and bring us a few down periods.

First, there were 6,203 single family detached closings in July. This is down 4.7% from July 05’, but after lags are reported we should be up at least 5%.

Condos and townhomes closed 1,011 units in July, which is up 1.4% before lags and should keep our streak of 38 double-digit percentage increases intact. There have been more condos and townhomes closed through July than we had in all of 2003.

The average sale price for condos and townhomes in July was $184,841 or the lowest average price so far in 2006 and the lowest since October 2005. How do you maintain 38 consecutive double-digit percentage increases for closings? Have an average price in a “July 06” that is below the overall average in 2003, 2004, and 2005.

The average price for condos and townhomes was almost $100M less than it was for single family detached. The average price of a condo and townhome in July was 66.2% for the average of a single family detached. In 2003, a condo and townhome’s average price was 79% that of a single family detached, but in July of 2006, one out of seven closings was a condo or townhome versus single family detached, while in 2003 it was one out of nine. Price is “everything” and the market always will reflect it.

The average price for single family detached was $278,110 in July. This is another new all-time high, but inventories and months-supply for single family detached is on the increase, so their prices should moderate.

I have created a new chart showing the relationship between months-supply and inventory for single family detached and condos & townhomes. As you can see, months-supply for single family detached has trended upward over the past 5 periods at a pace greater than normal. Condos and townhomes have also trended upward, but just slightly and actually back to a “normal” pace.

Months-supply trending is one of the best indicators for a housing market, because it illustrates the balance between supply and demand so well.

The number of expired listings for single family detached in July was 3,817. This is the seventh consecutive yearto-year increase (every period in 2006), after every period in 2005 had a year-to-year decline. The year-to-year increase was 688 or the largest increase since June 2002-2003.

Expired listings for condos and townhomes also increased, but not as much, going from 829 in July 2005 to 860 in July 2006. However, with increasing months-supply we will see record expired listings by the end of the year for both condos & townhomes and especially detached single family.

We have actually had some good economic news the past few weeks. Interest rates have declined about a third of a point since 6/29 and gas prices had a significant drop in price this past week. However, gas prices are much more volatile than interest rates and they can go up just as fast, but let’s hope both of these positive trends can continue.

Thank you,

Steve Palm
Smart Numbers
© 2006 Smart Numbers

Popularity: 7% [?]

June Market Update

Friday, July 21st, 2006

There were 7,990 single-family closings in June or a decrease of 3.3% from June 2005. After lags are reported, we should then have an increase.

I have to admit that I am surprised by the Atlanta real estate market’s resilience so far in 2006. After so much negative International news, higher interest rates, escalating energy prices, etc I would have thought our market would be “flat” at best, but we are up 7% over the first half of 2005.

Single family detached closings for June were down 4.0% at 6,846, while condos and townhomes were up 1.1% with 1,144 closings. We have had 36 consecutive double-digit year-to-year increases for condos and townhomes through May.

Atlanta’s large available lower priced inventory of housing, below $300,000 for detached single family and under $200,000 for condos and townhomes, have been the main reason why Atlanta has been more sheltered from a housing downturn than in other Metro areas across the US.

Smartnumbers covers most of the Southeast and some of the Florida Metro areas that really exploded in volume and price over the past few years are showing large declines this year. The Naples-Ft Myers area and the Miami-Palm Beach areas have closings down over 30% from the same year ago periods, while Panama City Beach has seen a 25% drop in condominium prices over the past 12 months.

Atlanta’s real estate prices have also been on the increase every year, but at a very moderate pace. The average annual price increase for all single family housing has been under 5.0% for the past 6 years, not 30-50% in some of those Florida markets mentioned above.

The average sale price was $264,206 for all single family in June. This was up only 3.2% from June 2005 and year-to-date is only 2.0% higher than 2005’s average price.

Single family detached set a new all-time high with an average sale price of $276,722, while condos and townhomes had an average sale price of $189,306 or a decrease of 2.9% from June 2005.

Inventories continue to increase more than normal and if this continues it will put pressure on prices not to increase or even decline. Inventories of single family detached have increased substantially this year, 10,000 units since 12/31/05, so pressure on pricing may show greater signs of flattening or even dropping in the second half of 2006.

August 2005 saw a spike in withdrawn listings that has continued through June 2006. As inventories increase, so does months-supply or the time it takes to sell a home. Consumers may be switching listings more, as we found 1,128 closings last month that were previously listed.

Days-on-market remained relatively low for all single family in June at 73.7. However, TDOM or total-days-onmarket, which takes into account previously listed time periods, was at 96.6. This also does not take into account listings that were withdrawn or expired and not re-listed. That is why months-supply is sometimes a better gauge for overall market time than days-on-market, and months supply is on the increase.

Thank you,

Steve Palm
Smart Numbers
© 2006 Smart Numbers

Popularity: 7% [?]

May Market Update

Wednesday, June 21st, 2006

The results being reported this month are both encouraging and discouraging. First, even with all the negative economic and political news that has evolved this year we had an up month.

We had 7,401 closings in May for single family housing or an increase of 2.7%. However, after lags have been reported, April is still negative. We are down only 90 single-family closings in April, so I consider that to be flat rather than negative. If this holds up, it would be our first down period since January 2003.

But May is back up and we are still up by a comfortable margin for the first 5 months of 2006. Single family detached had 6,400 closings in May or a 3.6% increase from May 2005. Condos and townhomes are actually showing a decrease of 2.2%, but after lags are reported, should be positive.

We had a few records broken for average-price in May. Single family detached had an average price of $268,094 in May. This easily surpassed the previous high of $265,094 set last June. This was also a 5.4% increase over the same year ago period and the greatest year-to-year increase so far in 2006.

Condos and townhomes had an average sale price of $198,346 in May. This is an increase of 7.7% over May 2005 and also an all-time high.

I talked with an agent last week and she said “you keep reporting an up market, but all I see is standing inventory.”

I asked her where she did most of her business and it was in East Cobb in the higher priced homes. I then looked up what the months supply was for $500,000+ homes in East Cobb in zip code 30067 and it was over 12, while a year ago it was around 9. This was a large year-to-year increase and I noted where East Cobb had a year to year increase in closings, but the average price was under $300,000. So, yes, one part of the market was down, but other price-points were still strong.

When a housing market starts to slow, traditionally it is the high end and rural or farther out markets that slow first. I believe months-supply reporting is one of the best ways to gauge a market. In May, months-supply went up considerably from April. Single family detached-new went from 8.1 to 8.7, single family detached-resale went from 6.5 to 7.1, condos and townhomes-new went from 7.2 to 7.8, and condos and townhomes-resale went from 9.3 to 9.8. However, looking year-year it was not as bad, but there is an underlying trend that does not look good.

Below is a table on the year to year and month to month trending for months-supply

May 06 April 06 May 05 April 05

Single Family Detached new 8.7 8.1 7.8 7.9

Single Family Detached resale 7.1 6.5 6.9 6.9

Condos and Townhomes new 7.8 7.2 7.7 8.0

Condos and Townhomes resale 9.8 9.3 11.7 11.7

2.3 -0.4

As you can see, the months-supply trend from April 06 to May 06 increased substantially, while from April 05 to May 05 it went down. If this trend continues, supply out pacing demand, prices will start to decline.

You can check months supply in the FMLS web site to see similar trends for the areas your office or business is located.

Thank you,

Steve Palm
Smart Numbers
© 2006 Smart Numbers

Popularity: 8% [?]